REVISED DATA ON FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT

PRESS NOTE

---

In an effort to bring the reporting system of FDI data in India into alignment with international best practices, the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP), Ministry of Commerce and Industry, in consultation with RBI, had constituted a committee in May 2002 comprising officials from RBI and DIPP to study this issue. The Committee studied the relevant conceptual and methodological issues and identified the data gaps involved in order to make necessary recommendations for strengthening the collection, compilation and reporting of FDI data. The Committee submitted its Report in October 2002 recommending that the FDI statistics should include, besides equity capital, ‘reinvested earnings’ (retained earnings of FDI companies) and ‘other direct capital’ (inter-corporate debt transactions between related entities) in accordance with the international best practices. The Committee also recommended that the steps be taken jointly by RBI and DIPP to expand the coverage of FDI statistics in India.

As a follow-up action to the submission of FDI Compilation Report, a Technical Monitoring Group (TMG) with representatives from RBI, DIPP, Department of Economic Affairs (DEA), Department of Company Affairs (DCA) and National Informatics Centre (NIC) was constituted by DIPP in November 2002 for speedy implementation of the recommendations made by the above Committee. The main focus of the TMG was to identify various components of FDI, which are operationally feasible and capture these components in a specified institutional framework and within a specified time period. TMG submitted its first Action Taken Report on June 27, 2003.

Proposed Coverage of FDI to India

After reviewing the international best practices as also some select country experiences, the TMG concluded that inclusion of the following fourteen items in Indian FDI data under three major heads would, by and large, comply with the reporting system in line with international best practices.

A. Equity Capital

1. Equity capital of unincorporated entities;
2. Non-cash acquisition against technology transfer, plant and machinery, goodwill, business development and similar considerations;
3. Control premium;
4. Non-competition fees.

B. Reinvested Earnings

5. Reinvested earnings of incorporated entities;
6. Reinvested earnings of unincorporated entities;
7. Reinvested earnings of indirectly held direct investment enterprises.

C. ‘Other capital’

8. Short-term and long-term inter-corporate borrowings;
9. Trade credit;
10. Suppliers credit;
11. Financial leasing;
12. Financial derivatives;
13. Debt securities; and
14. Land and buildings.

Against this background, RBI and DIPP jointly decided to expand the coverage of data on FDI, both inflow and outflow for 2000-01 and 2001-02. The revised data on FDI include all items indicated under equity capital (except non-cash acquisitions). The equity capital of unincorporated entities (Item no. 1 above) includes the equity capital of foreign banks’ branches in India. All items under the reinvested earnings have been included except reinvested earnings of indirectly held direct investment enterprises. Data under ‘Other Capital’ relate to short-term and long-term borrowing, trade credit (more than 180 days), suppliers’ credit (more than 180 days), and financial leasing. Thus, in this exercise, out of fourteen items stated above, the FDI data do not include the following six items viz, (i) non-cash acquisitions, (ii) reinvested earnings of indirectly held direct investment enterprises, (iii) short-term trade credit, (iv) financial derivatives, (v) debt securities and (vi) land & buildings. The TMG is exploring the feasibility of including these items in future.

Proposed coverage of FDI by India

Figures in respect of FDI by India (Indian investment abroad), hitherto reported in the Balance of Payment (BoP) statistics, comprised mainly the equity component similar to the treatment given to FDI inflows into India. Since the data on FDI to India are being revised according to the best international practices, there was a need to compile corresponding data on Indian investment abroad. Accordingly, comparable data on Indian investment abroad that include equity capital, reinvested earnings and ‘other capital’ have been compiled for fiscal 2000-01 and 2001-02.

Current Revision of Data on FDI

In line with the explanation given above, the revised data (which are at present provisional) for 2000-01 and 2001-02 are shown in Tables 1 and 2.

Table 1: Component-wise Revised FDI Data to India

($ US Million)

	Item/Year	2000-01	2001-02
I.	Revised FDI to India (a+b+c)	4029	6131
	(a) Equity	2400	4095
	(b) Reinvested Earnings	1350	1646
	(c) ‘Other Capital’	279	390
II.	FDI Data Currently Published	2342	3905
III.	Additional Amount on Account of Revision	1687	2226

Table 2: Foreign Direct Investment Abroad (by India)

(US $ Million)

	Item/Year	2000-01	2001-02
I.	Revised FDI Abroad	757	1390
	(a) Equity	344	570
	(b) Reinvested Earnings	339	699
	(c) ‘Other Capital’	74	121
II.	FDI Abroad data Currently Published	514	639
III.	Additional Amount on Account of Revision	243	751

Implications for the Balance of Payments

In terms of standard practice of BoP compilation, the above revision of FDI data would not affect India’s overall BoP position for these two years. In other words, the accretion to the foreign exchange reserves would not undergo any change. However, there would be changes in the composition of BoP. These changes relate to investment income, external commercial borrowings and errors and omissions. In case of reinvested earnings, there would be a contra entry (debit) of equal magnitude under investment income in the current account. ‘Other Capital’ reported as part of FDI inflow has been carved out from the figure reported under external commercial borrowings by the same amount. ‘Other Capital’ by Indian companies abroad and equity capital of unincorporated entities have been adjusted against the errors and omissions. Following the above methodology, appropriate changes have been made in the current and capital account transactions of BoP. As a result, the current account surplus during 2001-02, which amounted to US $ 1.4 billion, has been revised to a surplus of US $ 0.8 billion. Furthermore, the current account deficit during 2000-01 has increased from US $ 2.6 billion to US $ 3.6 billion. This is mainly on account of adjustment of reinvested earnings as a contra entry in the investment income as explained above. The other major change is the reduction in errors and omissions in both the years. In net terms, the errors and omissions have been revised from US $ (-) 588 million to US $ (-) 572 million during 2000-01 and from US $ 860 million to US $ 403 million during 2001-02. The detailed BoP data revised as per above have been released in a separate RBI press note on June 30, 2003.

Future Course of Action

In future, reinvested earnings and equity capital of unincorporated bodies would be included in FDI data on an annual basis, as these data are culled out from the balance sheets of the FDI companies. Every year these data would become available with a time lag of one year e.g., data for 2002-03 would be available by June 2004. Consequently, for these items, advance estimates will be incorporated in the BoP data until firm data become available with a time lag of one year.

For 2002-03, the data on reinvested earnings are estimated as the average of the previous two years of 2000-01 and 2001-02. In the future as well, there will be a regular one-year lag in the reporting of reinvested earnings. ‘Other Capital’ could be captured on a quarterly basis and would be reported together with quarterly dissemination of BoP statistics. The estimates for data on FDI for 2002-03 in the line of figures indicated in Tables 1 and 2 are presented in Tables 3 and 4

Table 3: Component-wise Revised FDI Data to India

($ US Million)

	Item/Year	2002-03
I.	Revised FDI to India (a+b+c)	4660
	(a) Equity	2700
	(b) Reinvested Earnings	1498
	(c) ‘Other Capital’	462
II.	FDI Data Currently Published	2574
III.	Additional Amount on Account of Revision	2086

Table 4: Foreign Direct Investment Abroad (by India)

(US $ Million)

	Item/Year	2002-03
I.	Revised FDI Abroad	1049
	(a) Equity	424
	(b) Reinvested Earnings	519
	(c) ‘Other Capital’	106
II.	FDI Abroad data Currently Published	459
III.	Additional Amount on Account of Revision	590

RBI and DIPP would jointly continue to monitor the compilation of FDI statistics through TMG until the reporting system relating to remaining items of FDI is stabilized.

The FDI Compilation Report and the first Action Taken Report of the TMG are available in RBI and DIPP websites (http://www.rbi.org.in/ and http://www.dipp.nic.in/).