PM’S
INTERVIEW TO ITAR TASS (RUSSIAN NEWS CHANNEL)
ITAR- TASS correspondent, Mr. Mikhail Gusman,
interviewed the Prime Minister, Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee. The
interview is being telecast today, on the eve of President Vladimir
Putin's visit to India. The Prime Minister expressed his views
on a wide gamut of issues - including international, national
and personal ones.
Following is the English rendering of the full
text of the interview, which was conducted in Russian and Hindi:
Q.1 Honourable Mr. Prime Minister, thank you
very much for finding time for us to have this interview. The
Russian President, Mr. Vladimir Putin is about to arrive on his
visit to India in a few days. How important do you think will
be your talks with him?
Ans: We are eagerly waiting for President Putin.
We attach great importance to his visit and talks with him. Russia
is an old friend of ours. We have a dynamic relationship, which
is constantly moving forward, and getting strengthened. There
is a great deal of commonality in the views of India and Russia
on international questions. We are also working in tandem in the
fields of economy and defence. As strategic partners, we will
discuss the international scenario. Regional situation and bilateral
relations will also figure in talks with him. This discussion
will be very significant.
Q.2 As far as I know, you have met the Russian
President quite a few times and have also established a personal
rapport with him. How much importance do you attach to this personal
rapport in furthering the relations between the two countries?
Ans I have a deep personal relationship with
President Putin. We keep meeting regularly. If need be, we talk
on the phone. Discussions are always very frank. There is no hesitation
in our hearts when we talk. He is a trusted friend and from this
point of view our personal relations help in strengthening our
political relations.
Q.3 As far as I know, you had a personal relationship
with several Russian leaders of different generations - from Leonid
Brezhnev to Vladimir Putin. What do you feel - how have your personal
relations with Kremlin leaders changed with times and where do
they stand today?
Ans It's a matter of great happiness for me that
I had the opportunity to meet, exchange views and have frank discussions
with Russian leaders from Mr. Brezhnev to President Putin. Whatever
changes have taken place, have further strengthened our friendship
because our friendship is based on principles and is rooted in
protection of mutual interests. This feeling of friendship has
stemmed from the resolve to work together and I am happy to note
that when I look back, a picture emerges in which there is continuity
with change, and along with personal rapport, there is also a
policy-related consensus. That is why we attach great value to
this visit of President Putin.
Q.4 Honourable Prime Minister, you have rightly
said that with changing times, our two countries have established
a strategic partnership. How much do you think will this strategic
partnership grow, in which direction and to what extent?
Ans We are confident that the strategic partnership
between us will forge ahead. There is a need to extend this partnership
further in the changed international circumstances. Our international
ideals are the same and we have been working together in every
field and can start working in new areas in the future. We will
discuss this with President Putin. How far we can take this strategic
partnership to new heights, and add depth to it - all these questions
will be discussed.
Q.5 Mr. Prime Minister, you have been to Russia
several times. You are well acquainted with Moscow. What does
our nation mean to you?
Ans I have had the opportunity to visit Russia
quite a few times. I have also been to Moscow. Each time my visit
has been successful. Russia is a friend, with whom our friendship
has always stood the test of time. Our friendship gets a boost
by whatever changes that take place in the world. We will discuss
about expanding our cooperation.
Q.6 Mr. Prime Minister, I would like to ask a
few personal questions, with your permission. Your father was
a school teacher and your education was of a very high standard.
Could tell us how your family and the atmosphere at your home
affected your life?
Ans The atmosphere in my family encouraged me
to work in public life. It was an atmosphere of education and
I studied different types of thoughts. In our family, there used
to be discussions from different point of views. As a student,
I participated in the movement, which was mainly related to India's
freedom struggle. However, side-by-side, there were discussions
on the nature of post-independence India. What will be our relations
with other nations - and the fact that we will maintain a close
relationship with Russia emerged constantly during these discussions.
We have stood by each other through thick and thin. And we understand
each other well. No attempts to create misunderstandings between
us have succeeded. The frank atmosphere within my family has helped
me to adopt this healthy attitude.
Q.7 In your younger days, you participated in
the freedom struggle, as you told us that at a very tender age,
at the age of 16, you were imprisoned. How did you endure the
hardships at such a tender age?
Ans The whole nation was fighting imperialism.
Youth were embracing death. Some people were waging an armed struggle
against foreign imperialism. Some were struggling to achieve independence
by adopting peaceful means of non-violence. I was born and brought
up in such an environment. It was natural that as I gained in
years, I became a part of the movement. It is correct that I was
imprisoned at the age of 16, but I still remember that I was kept
in the children's barrack. The amenities were less, but I did
not have to stay there for many days. The Government could not
prove the allegations against me. At that time participating in
the freedom struggle was like performing a sacred duty. It helped
me a great deal in moulding my public life in the future. We are
free today. Now in the era of freedom, we have a chance to fulfill
the dreams that we had seen earlier. Freedom is just a means,
not an end. Freedom gives us the opportunity to fight exploitation
and raise our voices against inequality and work for world peace.
From the beginning, I got these values from my family, from outside
the family and because of that I have been somewhat able to serve
the country, humbly and successfully.
Q. 8 About 50 years back, in 1951, the Bhartiya
Jan Sangh was established and you were among those who had established
the party. How did you come into politics? What were your objectives,
those of your party and the politics of those times?
Ans The struggle for freedom motivated me to
enter politics. At that time, Congress was a national forum. People
espousing different ideologies used to serve the country through
Congress. Initially, I too was associated with Congress. During
the college days also, I used to participate in students' federation.
Then, I came to know about the October revolution. A feeling that
we have to achieve economic independence also and for that I tried
to move forward by participating in student movement. Had the
Congress not accepted the partition of India, perhaps my association
with it would have continued. But, when the country was partitioned
due to imperialist conspiracy, I felt that I should tread a different
path. And we entered politics as "Jan Sangh" to build an effective
Opposition.
Q.9 You had been the Foreign Minister during
the end of seventies and nineties. You have established yourself
as a diplomat of a very high order. You have not only achieved
your goals but if need be, you know how to compromise. What according
to you is the role of compromise in international relations?
Ans Firmness is essential in all walks of life
and along with firmness flexibility is also required. There has
broadly been a general consensus on the question of foreign policy.
Therefore, change of guard has not led to any change in foreign
policy. That is why, when I got an opportunity as the Foreign
Minister, we were ready to follow the policy of non-alignment
because non-alignment was not the policy of just one party. During
an argument once I told Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru that even if you
had not followed non-alignment, the country would have tread it.
Now, the country is following this under your leadership, it's
a matter of happiness. Political differences have never distracted
us from our foreign policy. Whatever policy direction was needed
for country's larger interests and major issues of the world was
taken. A little amount of success has been achieved. All those
who helped us in achieving it, deserve thanks. I am happy about
whatever contribution I could make.
Q.10 Mr. Prime Minister, you have been elected
to the Parliament eleven times, which is a world record. And I
also know that in 1995, you were nominated as the "Best Parliamentarian"
of India. In your opinion what are the qualities to become such
a good Parliamentarian in whom the people could repose their confidence
so many times? What are the qualities required?
Ans There should be a spirit to serve. Commitment
towards ideals is required, authenticity is needed and a readiness
to work with others and eliciting their cooperation is also required.
These qualities are essential and are helpful in moving forward.
Q.11 Mr. Prime Minister, I have a slightly different
kind of request. You are known not only as a great politician
the world over, but people also know you as a very accomplished
poet. It would be very nice if you recite for our Russian audience,
a few lines from your favourite poem.
Ans During my youth, I got the motivation to
pen down poems during the freedom struggle. These poems were filled
with a feeling of love for the country. They depicted a bright
future for India. It was more like a discovery of how India could
become strong and prosperous. Later on, when political responsibilities
increased, the flow of writing poetry ebbed. Still whenever a
moment comes, which touches the chords of my heart, touches my
innermost self, I pen down a few lines in the form of a poem.
I express the moments of disappointment too and also see a ray
of hope. I will recite a short poem for your audience:
MÉÉÒiÉ xɪÉÉ MÉÉiÉÉ
cÚÆ ,
]Ú]ä cÖA iÉÉ®Éå
ºÉä {ÉÚE]ä ¤ÉɺÉÆiÉÉÒ º´É®, {ÉilÉ® BÉEÉÒ UÉiÉÉÒ àÉå =MÉ +ÉɪÉÉ
xÉ´ÉÆBÉÖE®,
ZÉ½ä ºÉ¤É {ÉÉÒãÉä
{ÉÉiÉ, BÉEÉäªÉãÉ BÉEÉÒ BÉÚEBÉE ®ÉiÉ ,
®ÉÉÊjÉ àÉå +É°ôÉÊhÉàÉÉ
BÉEÉÒ ®äiÉ näJÉ {ÉÉiÉÉ cÚÆ,
MÉÉÒiÉ xɪÉÉ
MÉÉiÉÉ cÚÆ* MÉÉÒiÉ xɪÉÉ MÉÉiÉÉ cÚÆ*
Last stanza is-
]Ú]ä cÖA ºÉ{ÉxÉä
BÉEÉÒ ºÉÖxÉä BÉEÉèxÉ ÉʺɺÉBÉEÉÒ,
]Ú]ä cÖA ºÉ{ÉxÉä
BÉEÉÒ ºÉÖxÉä BÉEÉèxÉ ÉʺɺÉBÉEÉÒ,
+ÉÆiÉ® BÉEÉä SÉÉÒ®
BªÉlÉÉ {ÉãÉBÉEÉå {É® ÉÊ~~BÉEÉÒ,
cÉ® xÉcÉÓ àÉÉxÉÚÆMÉÉ,
®É® xÉcÉÒ ~ÉxÉÚÆMÉÉ,
BÉEÉãÉ BÉEä BÉE{ÉÉãÉ
{É® ÉÊãÉJÉiÉÉ ÉÊàÉ]ÉiÉÉ cÚÆ,
MÉÉÒiÉ xɪÉÉ MÉÉiÉÉ
cÚÆ, MÉÉÒiÉ xɪÉÉ MÉÉiÉÉ cÚÆ **
Q.12 Many many thanks Mr. Prime Minister. I listened
to the translation of the poem that you have recited. But perhaps
a poem need not be translated. We could understand from its very
rhythm that how good is your poem. We are thankful to you for
giving us and our viewers a chance to listen to it. I would also
like to say that in Russia we have known about India through the
Indian films. Indian films are popular in almost every household
of Russia. Which Russian of my generation does not know about
Raj Kapoor. At this very moment I can sing before you the whole
music of his film "Awara". There was a time in Russia when you
could not find even a single child who could not sing many lines
of the songs from the film "Awara".
Ans. "Awara" has been very popular. "Awara's"
music was very popular, we all know this and salute the Russian
peoples' sense of appreciating music and art.
Q.13 Would you be able to tell us which of his
films and which one of his songs do you like most ?
Ans. It is very difficult to select one particular
song out of the many songs because all his songs are very good,
attractive and appeal to the heart. I enjoyed a very good relationship
with Raj Kapoor. I have been an admirer of his work. I liked his
film - "Mera Naam Joker" the most. But as far as the songs are
concerned 'Awara hoon' is certainly at the top.
Q.14 You are very right. We feel and have also
heard that you have one more hobby dear to you - and that is cooking.
Whenever you find time you like to cook certain traditional Hindustani
recipes. Would you please tell us, which is your favourite dish,
which would you like to cook and eat?
Ans. I practiced cooking during my student days.
I used to live in a hostel. My father also used to live with me.
He liked variety in food and it was my responsibility to cook
it. I learned cooking and can claim that I am one of the better
cooks. People like food prepared by me. I prefer "Khichdi".
Q.15 What type of "Khichdi", ordinary or something
very spicy?
Ans. Not very spicy but a little spice is required.
Q.16 I am asking this because when we eat in
India, it appears that there is fire all around.
Ans. It's not like that everywhere. Not so much
chillies are eaten. I too cannot eat much of chillies, but the
food should be somewhat spicy. It is necessary.
Q.17 You have put it most aptly. So far as the
word "spicy" is concerned we can, in a way, claim that you and
I are colleagues. You have been an editor - that too of three
papers. You must have come across a chance, when you came across
too much of criticism in a newspaper, at that time don't you remember
your own old days of editorship and feel that "no! no! this should
have been edited"?
Ans. Being an editor I always tried to work with
responsibility. I was in Opposition, member of the Opposition
party. I did not spare anyone in criticizing but always felt that
it was my duty to indulge in constructive criticism without crossing
the limits. Whatever I wanted to say, I said very clearly, but
used to choose such words in a way that the readers or the listeners
do not feel hurt.
Q.18 As a leader of the country you travel and
meet a lot of people. What do you feel - what are the kind of
people you like to meet or have felt nice after meeting. Which
are the people you feel speak the same language, or think in the
same way as you do?
Ans. I am in politics. Most of my time is spent
with my political friends. I try to elicit everybody's cooperation
in policy making. I also see that India is a big country - a country
of great diversities. There are a number of religions, a number
of languages. Food habits also vary. We have always underlined
the unity in diversity and that is why people living in any part
of the country, speaking any language become my friends. I convey
my feelings to them and also like to listen to their views. I
do not feel bad whenever there is criticism. These days I am being
criticized a lot. I learn from such criticism and wherever necessary,
change my policy and behaviour. But there are certain values,
which I would like to adhere strictly to. I do not compromise
with values.
Q.19 Mr. Prime Minister, you have been elected
Head of the Cabinet three times and last time you were awarded
as the 'Best Head of the Cabinet in Asia'. It's an onerous responsibility
and a very important one, how do you fulfill this?
Ans. I fulfill my responsibility with the cooperation
of all. I have faith in people and people have faith in me. I
do not hide anything from the people. I do not hesitate in saying
the right things. But I always keep an eye on the collective will
of the people and always try to ensure that I am able to establish
contact with the common man.
Q.20 Under your leadership, Mr. Prime Minister,
India has achieved a great deal of success in the economic field.
What do you feel - which policies have helped you in achieving
this success?
Ans. There has been a policy change in India
in the last few years. Earlier we had such policies, which could
help the country in facing different kinds of crisis. Thus, we
laid emphasis on heavy industries. We were concerned about our
defence. But now in our new policies we have made certain changes.
We have framed policies, which are pragmatic and which have been
worked out in keeping with the interests of the masses. There
has been an improvement in the economic situation in India and
we hope that this process of reforms will continue. We have always
been against the 'Quota Permit Raj'. It does not augur well that
all the powers, all the rights are centralized in the hands of
the Government. Government should be a facilitator, government
should cooperate, government should prepare an environment for
progress - it is very necessary. But if the government itself
starts doing everything, then we cannot expect good results. Now
with the new policies there is an improvement in India's economic
condition and we hope that there will be further improvement.
Q.21 In your view what should we do to increase
economic cooperation between Russia and India? Which one of the
long-term schemes should we adopt and, in these, how could our
cooperation in the military and technical fields be enhanced?
Ans. In the military field our cooperation is
constantly growing. We depend a lot on our friend Russia. On a
number of issues, in times of need, Russia has come to our help.
It has been our endeavour - that our cooperation in the nuclear
field should increase. We have faith in each other and that is
why we are able to get such technology from Asia, which we are
not able to get from other countries. Other countries try to place
hurdles in the way. They do not want that the friendship between
India and Russia should go deeper, or India should be provided
with such technology, which they themselves would not like to
part with. But we enjoy close relations with Russia and in this
context can depend on Russia during any crisis.
Q.22 Mr. Prime Minister, I am aware that you
are trying a lot to reach an accord with Pakistan. Do you feel
or look at any possibility of such an accord or settlement in
near future?
Ans. Pakistan is our neighbour. We want to live
in friendship with it but a friendship cannot be one-sided. One
can clap only with both hands. I had gone to Lahore with a message
of friendship and peace. But almost at the same time an attack
was made on Kargil. Despite this, we invited Gen. Musharraf to
Agra. But he did not agree to abandon his policy of cross-border
terrorism. There cannot be any meaningful dialogue with Pakistan
due to continued terrorism, which is being abetted and sponsored
from across the border. If Pakistan could abandon the path of
terrorism, then both the countries can work together. We can help
each other in economic areas. We can increase regional cooperation.
We wish that SAARC should be strengthened further. We are expanding
our relations with the other countries of South Asia. But it is
necessary that whatever cooperation is there should be based on
principles.
Q.23 Mr. Prime Minister, very often an interview
is concluded with the question of this type, I too would like
to ask you the same question. Every man has one or the other aim
in his life, which is often like this that what would I like to
do in my career. How would I like to achieve success in life?
What would be your message, your advice to the youth in Russia
and India that what aim should they have in their lives, in their
careers? How can they achieve success? What would you like to
say to them particularly, based on experiences of your life and
success?
Ans. The new generation is facing the challenges
of the new century. We have to face the challenges of the new
century, to work for peace, to work for equality and brotherhood.
We have to build a world which is free from fear and hunger and
which is concerned for everybody's welfare. We want to take our
own country also in this direction. Youth have a great future
- magnificent future. The type of facilities available to youth
of today was not there fifty years ago. I remember there was no
electricity in our house. I used to study in the light of a kerosene
oil lamp. But there was a will, a determination and that inspired
me to move ahead. I want the youth to work for their future and
at the same time work for the future of the country and the world.
Everybody lives for self, but a part of life should be devoted
to others too.
Q.24 Many many thanks Mr. Prime Minister. You
have spared a lot of time for us. We are grateful to you for this
and particularly happy that our viewers in Russia will get a chance
to see your interview on their televisions.
Ans. I am also very happy to meet you. You have
asked such questions which I had to answer and a number of things
emerged, which are normally not discussed. Who cares about what
I eat - but you did!
Q.25 We are very grateful for the interview and
highly appreciate it.
Ans. Thank You.